Consumer Title Resource | Since 2009!

Are “Buy Your Car” Companies Backing Out Of Offers? (Carvana, Shift, Vroom, Carmax?)

In both our Vehicle Title Division and Investigative Division, an unprecedented surge in inquiries has caught our attention. Over the last 30 to 45 days, we’ve been inundated with reports from consumers sharing their experiences with online vehicle purchase companies, such as CarMax, Carvana, Vroom, Shift, and others. What’s the common thread? Rescinded or reneged offers.

The Online Vehicle Purchase Landscape: An Overview

These companies have revolutionized the way people sell their cars. Offering to buy vehicles even if you don’t buy from them, they provide platforms where you input your vehicle details, receive an offer, submit photos, and, if satisfied, they send a truck to pick up your vehicle, paying you for it regardless of whether you purchase a car from them. It’s a seemingly straightforward process, but a recent spike in reported issues raises questions about what might be transpiring behind the scenes.

The Rescinded Offer Phenomenon: Unveiling the Trends

  1. Alarming Increase in Reports:
    • In the last month and a half, we’ve witnessed an exponential rise in consumers reporting that, after accepting an offer and providing the necessary documentation, they were left in the dark – the company never followed through.
  2. Ghosted by Car Companies:
    • The common narrative is eerily similar. Consumers describe accepting an offer, receiving an email confirmation, and then experiencing radio silence. Follow-up attempts are met with silence or vague responses, leaving sellers bewildered.
  3. Possible Reasons Behind the Surge:
    • The sudden surge in reports prompts speculation about the reasons. Is it due to the rapidly dropping car market? Are these companies reassessing their offers as book values plummet and auction results indicate a significant decrease in vehicle values?

Consumer Experiences: Tales of Frustration and Disappointment

  1. Late Model Toyota:
    • One client shared their experience of bringing in a late-model Toyota SUV to a location that typically doesn’t provide pick-up services. Despite a clean title, the company cited an old lien record as a reason not to purchase the vehicle – a questionable explanation given their actions on the same day.
  2. Daily Follow-Ups:
    • There are instances of clients diligently sending daily emails, desperately trying to sell their cars, only to face constant ignorance from the car companies. Emails warning of offer expiration go unanswered, leading to mounting frustration.

Potential Industry Dynamics: Are Tech Companies Struggling?

  1. Stock Price Drops and Regulatory Questions:
    • Companies like Carvana, facing drops in stock prices and regulatory inquiries, hint at potential underlying issues. Are these online platforms facing challenges in making a profit, given their high cost basis for vehicle acquisitions?
  2. Long-Term Profitability of Tech Companies:
    • The automotive business operates differently from tech markets. Tech companies often employ strategies of losing money to gain market share, a tactic challenging to execute in an industry where customers don’t make frequent purchases.

A Call to Action: Seeking Your Insights

We are reaching out to our community for insights. Have you encountered a similar experience when selling your car through online platforms? Are these companies reneging on offers due to market fluctuations? If you’re an employee in the industry, are you witnessing a shift in business practices?

Navigating Uncertainties

As we navigate this surge in rescinded offers, it’s imperative to stay informed. Whether you’re a consumer, an industry insider, or a regulatory authority, your insights can contribute to understanding the dynamics at play. Let us know your thoughts in the comments, and stay tuned for further updates as we strive to unravel the mysteries behind this unsettling trend. Until next time!

Have Title Questions? Talk to a Car Title Expert.

Book a consultation with a Car Title Expert from to get personalized guidance on your title recovery journey.

Don’t let uncertainty hold you back. If it’s your car, you deserve a title.

Share this article!

Check Your VIN Instantly:

Powered by